House Hopefuls Say Primary Rival
is Faking Residency in Open Race

Capitol Inside
December 30, 2021

A pair of Republican primary rivals are accusing former Southlake Mayor Laura Hill of skirting state law with an empty apartment that she rented recently to meet the residency requirements for an open race for the Texas House 93 seat in Tarrant County in 2022.

HD 93 contenders Cary Moon and Nate Schatzline submitted a formal complaint on Thursday to the Tarrant County GOP amid the assertion that the home that Hill now claims is a sham. Shatzline and Moon contended that Hill is a longtime resident of the Fort Worth suburb of Southlake where she still lives.

Hill's two first-round foes want the local party organization to reverse a decision to approve her application for a spot on the March 1 primary ballot in the competition to replace GOP State Rep. Matt Krause of Fort Worth in HD 93. Krause is giving up the House seat after 10 years in favor of a bid for Tarrant County district attorney instead next year.

Moon and Schatzline argue that Hill's ballot application was flawed because she failed to list a permanent address beyond a zip code in Haltom City that isn't in HD 93. Hill's opponents said it was evident that the ex-mayor and longtime council member from Southlake wasn't really a resident in HD 93 when a Schatzline canvassing worker noticed that multiple campaign doorhangers had ramined on the front door of her ostensible new living quarters in the district where she's running.

Hill wouldn't be the first legislative candidate in Texas to have two or more residences including official homesteads that are located outside districts they're competing to represent. The practice is common in a state where the legal residency restrictions have only been for show and rarely enforced.

Hill was elected to the Southlake council initially in 2004. She served six years as mayor before leaving office in 2019. Hill runs family businesses that specialize in yellow pages publishing and ice cream. Hill is touting perennial votes to cut property taxes. She's also taking credit for staving off efforts to defund the police and spread critical race theory in the public schools.

Moon has significant experience at the local level as well - having served on the Fort Worth City Council for a half-dozen years. "Cary injects his conservative principles, professional skills, and experience to make sure Fort Worth does not become Austin nor Dallas," according to Moon's campaign web site.

Schatzline is a conservative activist who founded an organization called For Liberty & Justice that seeks to reform government through a coordinated effort by churches.

“Laura Hill clearly doesn’t live in the apartment she falsely claimed as her residence,” Schatzline said. “Her ballot application misrepresents her residency. What voters want is someone who will fight for the truth and tell the truth. Her ballot application is not truthful. She should be removed.”

Moon seconded the objection.

"There is a fair process for candidates to document and to establish residency within a district," Moon said. "Texas law is in place to ensure representation for people, by people, who live in the same district. A stark error has been made. The Tarrant County GOP should have a cure for the default, otherwise the application is void."

 
 

1

House District 150 - GOP
Valoree Swanson (Inc)
Brian Le
Valerie McGilvrey
Debbie Riddle

2

House District 31 - GOP
Ryan Guillen (Inc)
Alena Berlanga
Mike Monreal

3

House District 62 - GOP
Reggie Smith (Inc)
Shelley Luther

4

House District 79 - DEM
Art Fierro (Inc)
Claudia Ordaz Perez (Inc)

5

House District 60 - GOP
Glenn Rogers (Inc)
Kit Marshall
Mike Olcott
Lucas Turner

6

House District 53 - GOP
Andrew Murr (Inc)
Wes Virdell

7

House District 91 - GOP
Stephanie Klick (Inc)
Ben Damico
David Lowe
Anthony Reed
David Silvey

8

House District 68 - GOP
David Spiller (Inc)
Craig Carter
Gary Franklin
Mark Middleton

9

House District 98 - GOP
Giovanni Capriglione (Inc)
Mitchell Ryan

10

House District 11 - GOP
Travis Clardy (Inc)
Greg Caldwell
Rachel Hale
Mark Williams

11

House District 6 - GOP
Matt Schaefer (Inc)
Charles Turner

12

House District 2 - GOP
Bryan Slaton (Inc)
Clyde Bostwick

13

House District 138 - GOP
Lacey Hull (Inc)
Josh Flynn

14

House District 5 - GOP
Cole Hefner (Inc)
Dewey Collier

15

House District 121 - GOP
Steve Allison (Inc)
Michael Champion

16

House District 1 - GOP
Gary Vandeaver (Inc)
George Lavender
Ray Null

17

House District 12 - GOP
Kyle Kacal (Inc)
Ben Bius
Joshua Hamm

18

House District 3 - GOP
Cecil Bll Jr. (Inc)
Kelly McDonald

19

House District 14 - GOP
John Raney (Inc)
John Harvey Slocum

20

House District 18 - GOP
Ernest Bailes (Inc)
Janis Holt
Steven Missick
Bubba Tullos

21

House District 45 - DEM
Erin Zwiener (Inc)
Jessica Mejia
Angela Villescaz

22

House District 42 - DEM
Richard Peña Raymond (Inc)
Jorge "JD" Delgado

23

House District 142 - DEM
Harold Dutton (Inc)
Candis Houston

24

House District 15 - GOP
Steve Toth (Inc)
Maris Blair

25

House District 132 - GOP
Mike Schofield (Inc)
Erik Le

 

1

House District 93 - GOP
Laura Hill
Cary Moon
Nate Schatzline

2

House District 13 - GOP
Angelia Orr
Dennis Wilson

3

House District 114 - DEM
John Bryant
Charles Gearing
Alexandra Guio
Chris Leal
Kendall Scudder

4

House District 19 - GOP
Justin Berry
Nubia Devine
Perla Hopkins
Ellen Troxclair

5

House District 133 - GOP
Shelley Torian Barineau
Emilio DeAyala
Will Franklin
Bert Keller
Greg Travis

6

House District 38 - DEM
Erin Gamez
Jonathan Gracia

7

House District 122 - GOP
Adam Blanchard
Elisa Chan
Mark Cuthbert
Mark Dorazio

8

House District 17 - GOP
Jen Bezner
Stan Gerdes
Tom Glass
Paul Pape
Trey Rutledge

9

House District 37 - DEM
Ruben Cortez
Frank Puente
Luis Villarreal Jr.

10

House District 73 - GOP
Barron Casteel
George Green
Carrie Isaac

11

House District 76 - DEM
James Burnet
Sarah DeMerchant
Vanesia Johnson
Suleman Lulani

12

House District 57 - GOP
Matthew Haines
Richard Hayes
Matthew Pool

13

House District 84 - GOP
David Glasheen
Cheryl Little
Carl Tepper
Kade Wilcox

14

House District 63 - GOP
Ben Bumgarner
Jake Collier
Nick Sanders
Jeff Younger

15

House District 65 - GOP
Robert Cooksey
Peyton Inge
Kronda Thimesch

16

House District 127 - GOP
Charles Cunningham
Deanna Robertson

17

House District 51 - DEM
Cody Arn
Bino Cadenas
Clair Campos-O'Neal
Lulu Flores
Mike Hendrix
Cynthia Valdez-Mata
Matt Worthington

18

House District 52 - GOP
Caroline Harris
Nelson Jarrin
Patrick McGuinnes
Jonathan Schober

19

House District 61 - GOP
Pat Chabot
Frederick Frasier
James Herblin

20

House District 147 - DEM
Danielle Keys Bess
Somtoochukwu Ik-Ejiofor
Reagan Denise Flowers
Akwete Hines
Joland Jones
Nam Subramanian
Aurelia Wagner

21

House District 92 - DEM
Salman Bhojani 
Tracy Scott
Dinesh Sharma

 

Copyright 2003-2022 Capitol Inside